Custom concrete gunite pool with spa and water features in a Bluffton SC backyard
Buyer's Guide

Fiberglass vs. Concrete Pools — An Honest Comparison

June 4, 20267 min readWest Bay Pools Team

If you've spent any time researching pool types, you've probably come across a lot of articles making the case for fiberglass. Lower maintenance, faster installation, great value. What those articles don't always mention is who wrote them. A large portion are published by fiberglass manufacturers or dealers who sell fiberglass exclusively, and that shapes the story considerably.


We build concrete pools, and we've also renovated plenty of fiberglass ones. We'll say both of those things upfront. That experience on both sides gives us a pretty clear picture of where each type actually lands over time, and it doesn't always match what gets written online.

How the two types compare

Concrete (Gunite)Fiberglass
Base cost (2026)From ~$59,995From ~$59,900
Structural lifespanIndefinite with periodic resurfacingFull shell replacement at 20–30 years
ResurfacingEvery 15–25 years — straightforward processGel coat repairs require specialty contractors
Design flexibilityFully custom — any shape, size, depthLimited to pre-formed shell sizes and shapes
Renovation potentialAdd features, reconfigure, expand any timeEssentially fixed once installed
Hydrostatic risk (Lowcountry)Minimal — mass and structure resist upliftReal risk if drained on a high water table

Lifespan is the biggest difference

A fiberglass shell has a finite lifespan. The gel coat surface degrades over time from UV exposure, chemical contact, and temperature cycling. Manufacturers typically quote 20 to 30 years before a fiberglass pool needs significant structural attention, and in many cases that means replacing the shell entirely, which is a major undertaking.


A concrete pool, properly built and maintained, doesn't have a structural lifespan in the same sense. The interior finish gets resurfaced every 15 to 25 years, which resets the surface and gives you a chance to update the look at the same time. The shell underneath keeps going. There are concrete pools across the Southeast that are 40 and 50 years old and still in excellent shape.


For most homeowners making a $100,000+ investment in their backyard, this difference matters a lot more than it tends to get discussed.

Concrete gunite pool with custom coping and deck at a Bluffton SC home
Concrete gives you complete freedom in design — and the ability to change your mind later.

A Lowcountry-specific consideration

The water table in much of Bluffton, Hilton Head, and the surrounding area sits close to the surface. This is something every pool builder in this market thinks about, and it affects fiberglass pools in a specific way.


When a fiberglass pool is drained, the hydrostatic pressure from groundwater pushing upward can cause the shell to shift or lift partially out of the ground. It's not common, but it happens, and when it does it's a serious problem. A displaced fiberglass shell typically can't be repositioned, and a replacement is often the only option.


Concrete pools carry far less risk here. The structure is bonded to the earth through the gunite shell, the rebar framework, and the sheer mass of the build. Concrete pools also have hydrostatic relief valves in the floor. It's still not something you'd do casually, but draining a concrete pool for service or renovation is a routine part of ownership.

Worth knowing regardless of pool type: You should never drain a pool in the Lowcountry without talking to your builder first. Hydrostatic pressure is real in this area. Your builder can guide you through doing it safely.

The cost picture has changed

A few years ago, fiberglass pools came in noticeably below a comparable concrete build. The shell is pre-manufactured and installation is faster, so the savings were real.


That gap has compressed. In 2026, base pricing for a fiberglass pool starts around $59,900 and concrete around $59,995 — a difference that effectively disappears once you account for site conditions, equipment, and finishing. And when you look at the full ownership timeline, the math shifts further: concrete resurfacing every 15 to 25 years is a predictable, manageable cost. A fiberglass shell replacement at 20 to 30 years is a much larger project. Over a 40-year horizon, concrete almost always ends up the better value.

On the maintenance question

The lower-maintenance claim for fiberglass gets repeated constantly, and it used to carry more weight. The argument is that a smoother surface gives algae fewer places to take hold, which is true in principle.


In practice, the difference is pretty small today. Modern concrete finishes — pebble, quartz aggregate, and properly applied waterproofing systems — have closed the gap considerably. The pools we're building now are not the rough-gunite surfaces of 30 years ago that the fiberglass marketing tends to reference. We see fiberglass and concrete pools side by side all the time, including when we're brought in to renovate fiberglass pools, and day-to-day maintenance is not meaningfully different between the two when both are well built.


What fiberglass can't offer is flexibility down the road. If you want to add a tanning ledge, change the steps, or reconfigure the depth in 10 years, a fiberglass shell simply won't allow it. Concrete can be renovated at any point. Your pool can grow with how your family uses it.

What we build and why

We build gunite pools, the concrete method used in custom residential construction. Every West Bay pool starts from a blank page: your lot, your family, how you actually use a pool. No catalog of shapes to pick from, no size constraints.


We build in concrete because we think it's the right material for this market. The long lifespan, the repair-ability, the flexibility to renovate, and the structural resilience in a high water table environment all point the same direction. We're happy to talk through the specifics for your situation and show you what the process looks like.

Ready to Get Started?

Have questions about your project? Our team is happy to help — no obligation.

Get A Free Consultation